Overall rating: 2 stars
My husband was giving me a hard time the other day about the fact that I don't have many books that are rated 2 or 3 stars. I explained to him that it pains me to use my few writing minutes to write about a bad book when there are so many good books out there... But since Lorelei insisted we check almost every single one of these books out from the library, I feel compelled to blog about these silly books.
In short, they are the equivalent of cheap plastic toys that get played with a few times and then left in the playroom to take up space and gather dust.
The only one with any redeeming qualities is the original Pinkalicious, because it has the saying: "You get what you get, and you don't get upset." Of course, the little girl does get upset, so it's not much of a learning moment for her. But the gist of the story is that Pinkalicious (what is her real name?!) eats too many pink cupcakes even after her parents tell her to stop, and she turns pink. She even eats more after that; only when she turns red does she heed her doctor's advice and eat everything green in her family's refrigerator.
In Pink Around the Rink
Goldalicious
In another paperback book, Tickled Pink
I don't even want to waste your time by describing the rest of them. Lazy? Maybe, but...you get the idea. While I'm glad Lorelei is interested in books, and almost any book is better than no book at all, I would probably return these if someone gave her them as a gift. There are too many other wonderful ones, and these are just plain silly.
Julia, our resident 5 year old critic, loves pink. But even that can't get her to enjoy the Pinkalicious sequels. She told me when she first excitedly found and read Goldalicious, "It's like Moon Sand." Moon Sand is the totally crappy play doh cousin that has amazing infomercials on all the kid's channels. It looks like it will change your life, but when you try to play with it it just falls apart and makes a big mess. Any time something doesn't live up to the hype in our house Julia says that "It's just like Moon Sand." :)
ReplyDeleteThat said, we do love the illustrations in Pinkalicious and the pediatrician who prescribes green foods, ha!